1974 Conference III Champions
1974 Rutgers Cup Champions
1976 Conference III Champions
1978 Conference III Champions
2013 Conference II Champions
2013 Long Island Champions-Conference II
2013 Rutgers Cup Champions
Coach Matt McLees' Record at Carey
1991- 3-4-1
1992- 6-3**
1993- 5-3
1994- 1-7
1995- 6-2
1996- 4-4
1997- 6-3**
1998- 6-3**
1999- 4-4
2000- 5-3
2001- 5-3
2002- 7-2**
2003- 2-5
2004- 4-4*
2005- 7-3***
2006- 5-3*
Total 76-56-1
Coach Mike Stanley's Record at Carey
2007- 5-4**
2008- 7-3**
2009- 6-4**
2010- 10-1***
2011- 6-4**
2012- 7-3**
2013-12-0****
****Denotes Big Four Champions, Nassau County Champions and Long Island Champions
***Denotes Big Four Champions and County Finalist
**Denotes Big Four Champions and County Semi-Finalist
* Denotes Playoff Qualifier